Neufeld Institute

Smartfeed

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Boys are NOT Stupid!

'

Per Wikipedia, "Feminism is a collection of movements aimed at defining, establishing, and defending equal political, economic, and social rights and equal opportunities for women." Equal being the key word here.

I am ALL FOR equality.

I am NOT for boys being left in the dust. In her article Feminism Shames Young Boys, Pelle Billing says this:

The effect of teachers bringing feminism into the classroom, whether they are feminists themselves or simply instructed to do so, is that young boys hear the message: “Girls are good, boys are bad.” Due to their cognitive development, this is the natural interpretation of feminism for young boys (and girls). This creates a sense of shame at a very deep level, and could quite conceivably affect the self-esteem and healthy development of these young boys.
She goes on to say this:
Let’s have a passionate gender debate amongst adults, but leave children alone, and stop telling them that there’s something wrong with them simply because they were born male.




Christina Hoff Sommers tackles this issue in her book The War Against Boys, and one commenter on the book said perfectly what I was trying to articulate myself.
The problem with feminism is not that it has fostered achievement for women. Rather it is feminism's attempts to demean the roles and achievements of men and "feminize" boys that are problematic. To the extent that feminism has encouraged girls and women to strive for excellence, it should be lauded. To the extent that it has used our institutions, particularly our schools, as a vehicle to establish a so-called "new feminist order" at the expense of our sons, it is shameful.
Of great concern to me, as a mother of 2 sons, is that boys are falling behind in education. From elementary schools to high schools, boys have lower grades, lower class rank, and fewer honors than girls. They’re 50%more likely to repeat a grade in elementary school and one-third more likely to drop out of high school.

What I also find to be beyond troublesome is that boys are now being marketed to be stupid. The apparently popular book "Boys are Stupid. Throw Rocks at Them" has this product description on Amazon. "Girls, here it is—everything you need to know about boys: 1. Boys come from the Stupid Factory. 2. Boys are pretty much smelly and useless. 3. It is possible to have fun with boys, however..... 4. If you decide to keep a boyfriend, he will need to be housebroken." It is described as "edgy freshness." I think it's garbage. How will MY sons feel if they see a girl wearing this shirt?



But is feminism really to blame here? In an article in Dissent from 2006 titled The War Against Boys, Michael Kimmel points out:
If boys are doing worse, whose fault is it? To many of the current critics, it’s women’s fault, either as feminists, as mothers, or as both. Feminists, we read, have been so successful that the earlier “chilly classroom climate” has now become overheated to the detriment of boys. Feminist-inspired programs have enabled a whole generation of girls to enter the sciences, medicine, law, and the professions; to continue their education; to imagine careers outside the home. But in so doing, these same feminists have pathologized boyhood. Elementary schools are, we read, “anti-boy”—emphasizing reading and restricting the movements of young boys. They “feminize” boys, forcing active, healthy, and naturally exuberant boys to conform to a regime of obedience, “pathologizing what is simply normal for boys,” as one psychologist puts it.
However, he goes on to say:
Perhaps the real “male bashers” are those who promise to rescue boys from the clutches of feminists. Are males not also “hardwired” toward compassion, nurturing, and love? If not, would we allow males to be parents? It is never a biological question of whether we are “hardwired” for some behavior; it is, rather, a political question of which “hardwiring” we choose to respect and which we choose to challenge... By contrast, feminists believe that men are better than that, that boys can be raised to be competent and compassionate, ambitious and attentive, and that men are fully capable of love, care, and nurturance. It’s feminists who are really “pro-boy” and “pro-father”—who want young boys and their fathers to expand the definition of masculinity and to become fully human.


So who caused this problem? I don't know, and the truth is, I don't care. It doesn't matter who I pin the blame to, it doesn't solve the problem. And what I want are solutions. What I want is for my boys to have the same equal opportunities as your girls, and vice versa. What I want is for NO ONE to be left behind. What I want is for my boys to not be subjected to this kind of garbage.





What I want is for my boys not to be shamed just because they are boys.

I don't have any overnight solutions. I know we can not feed it by purchasing the garbage I've pictured here. I believe conscious parenting will have an effect. The more children raised with respect, compassion, and empathy, the more respect, compassion, and empathy will permeate society. We need to be conscious of the messages were sending to our children, conscious of what messages they're getting from the media. We need to discuss these topics with our chidren when it is age-appropriate to do so.

As one mom put it in the video Do Boys Get a Bad Rap, "Instead of putting the emphasis on "feminism," we should be putting the emphasis on "humanism," as in "all human beings should be treated with respect."

8 comments:

  1. Great post! One great book I love is "Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Life of Boys" by Michael Thompson and Dan Kindlon a must read for every mother of boys. Boys do get a bad rap as being bad and stupid and the truth is they are not.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, Lorelei. I'll have to check out that book.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post, well said. Had never heard of that book, it's appalling! What I usually do is to change words, so if I wouldn't find it acceptable to say it about women/ Irish people/ anything that I am, then it's not OK to say it about others.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "What I usually do is to change words, so if I wouldn't find it acceptable to say it about women/ Irish people/ anything that I am, then it's not OK to say it about others."

    That's what I do too. Any sentence demeaning men I simply reverse the genders so it reads 'women' & then see how I feel about it then.

    Great post, thank you so much for writing it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. While I understand your point in the article, I think you misunderstand (or are misinformed) about the tenets of feminism. I am a feminist, and I have a son. The feminism that I practice (and that all the many feminists that I know, including men, practice) supports working toward the betterment of society for all groups, including those comprised of women AND men (and other groups.) I feel that your post does the same thing to feminists that many others before have done, which is to bash feminism and try to make it inconsequential. The types of posters/shirts/etc. that you featured in the post are not promoted by feminists, at least not by me and those I know. I certainly want my son to do well, and part of being a feminist is instilling in him a value for all people. Please don't make make the "f" word (feminism) a bad word without understanding what it really is, not just what society typically perceives it to be. Thank you for reading my comment.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think feminism should be made a bad word, as it appears to me only a destructive force in present-day western society.

    All feminism, radical or not, is derived from radical feminist teaching, which is further & further diluted the more it is taken on by the masses. These people (the mass of self-professed feminists) never stop to think of where their actual beliefs come from, & genuinely if naively think that they are actually supporting equality (as opposed to female supremacy). But these often well-intentioned people do not write the core texts that are taught in gender studies classes. They don't teach gender studies classes. All of the women who invented feminist theory, basically all of the feminists from the seventies you can still name today - the Catherine Mackinnons, The Andrea Dworkins, Valerie Solanas, Germaine Greer - all of them were radical feminists & all of them expressed deeply contemptuous (& sometimes genocidal) views on men.
    None of them gave any thought to the problems or inequalities faced by men, - in particular the problems & inequalities brought about by feminism, & the same is true today. To most active feminists men aren't even fully human, only a problem to be dealt with, their lives only relevant in so far as they help or inconvenience women.

    Feminism is entirely about female self-interest, not equality, & has never carried out even one action in all of the 40 years it has been campaigning to help men & boys in any way. It has, however, done a marvelous job of PR in selling itself as pro-equality. But to anyone caring enough to look twice at its history, its hateful actions speak for themself.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree. Feminism has done a lot more harm than good in the time that it's been around. I don't take to the mistreatment of women, not at all. But when you takeit out on us, that's a problem too. The fact is; no matter how good your intentions may be, feminism hurts everyone EXCEPT the men who are actually misogynic. Misandry does nothing to hurt misogynists, it only hurts nice law-abiding men, and it only adds fuel to the fire. So please re-examine your true motives and beliefs and see if feminism is still the "equal" rights movement you think it is.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.