What about hers?
Of course not?
Then why on Earth would you ignore hers?
I am, at times, taken aback by the practices we, culturally, will accept and perform without question.
A friend recently asked for advice on her Facebook page because she said her child's (a preschooler) reaction to anything was to cry. As I set there reading her friends' recommendations, my heart sank. Most all of them told her to ignore him when he cries. Some said to punish him or send him away, and my thought was my goodness, where is the empathy?
Empathy is lacking in American culture all over the board, but a severe lack of empathy in dealing with children's emotions is disturbingly prevalent. We are given the advice to ignore them almost as soon as they come out of the womb in a sad and misguided attempt to "train" them, from allowing them to helplessly cry in their crib so that they learn to "self-soothe" to ignoring the screams of a distressed toddler so she doesn't "continue throwing fits for attention" to ignoring the cries of preschoolers and older children so as not to spoil them, and, for boys, feminize them. (Yes, sadly that is still a problem).
Our friends tells us they do it. The internet tells us it is okay. Some parenting experts advise it. Perhaps even your pediatrician may recommend it. However, the fact that everyone else is doing it doesn't make it right, neither does the fact that it is socially acceptable. I could bore you with study after study of the negative effects on children's brains and emotional development when they are ignored, left to cry alone without the comfort a parent's loving arms, but for goodness' sake, I shouldn't have to. Where is our moral compass?
How did we come to accept and believe it is okay to ignore our children when they are upset? Is it the lack of empathy shown to us when we were children that makes it so easy for us to be apathetic to it?
What a child doesn't receive, he can seldom later give. - P.D. JamesIt seems we have come to the conclusion that there are only 2 options. Give in to their cries, thereby spoiling them and turning them into dreadful brats, or ignoring them to keep that from happening.
But there is a wonderful third option! One that doesn't give in to the child, nor isolate the child.
EMPATHY. It doesn't come easily to many of us, especially if we were deprived of it as children ourselves, but it can, and should be, learned and passed down generation to generation. I will not, for the sake of post length, get into allowing infants to cry-it-out as I will certainly go off on a tangent, but for toddlers, preschoolers, and the older child, it looks something like this.
Your toddler is tired and cranky. The slightest thing sends him over the edge into a huge crying fit. I can tell you with certainty that he is not breaking down for his benefit. He is not manipulating you or trying to make your life difficult. He is overwhelmed, and giving him comfort will no more make him want to have more meltdowns than your friend giving you a shoulder to lean on will make you want to have to lean on her more. Don't withhold affection or attention during his time of distress. He needs you.
If your preschooler wants a cookie for breakfast, and you deny her the cookie causing her to cry, there is no need to ignore her OR give her the cookie. The third option allows you to say "I see that you are upset over the cookie. You really want it, but that isn't a healthy breakfast and I want you to be healthy." Understand her view. Validate her feelings. She is a human being.
If your older child pouts or cries because you won't buy him a new video game, sending him to his room isn't going to resolve his feelings, but only cause more negative feelings to build. You know what it is like to want things and not be able to get them. You probably experience that feeling every payday! I do! Empathize. "You're upset about the video game. I know what that feels like. I'm sorry you're feeling this way. I just cannot get it right now." Sure, it may require a whole lot more patience from you than sending him away or blocking him out, but remember...
You're not managing an inconvenience, you're raising a human being. - Kittie Frantz
If you'd like to support Positive-parents.org, please make a donation through the button below. All donations are greatly appreciated!
Pin It Now!